Take a regular ol' muffin tin, put a tiny dog treat--or a single piece of kibble--in each cup, and cover each treat up with a toy:
Encourage your dog to use his/her sense of smell to notice the treats, and sit back to watch the fun. Pao Pao figured out how to pick up the toys with his mouth and remove them from the tin to uncover the treat below:
He also used the paw-and-dislodge method:
At times he appeared a bit baffled by what was going on:
And sometimes he erroneously thought the dislodged toys held the treats:
But his nose kept returning him to the muffin tin and the treats that lay within:
It was really fun to watch him figure it all out:
If you didn't have enough dog toys, you could use small wood blocks, matchbox cars, or anything that partially obscures the treat but doesn't totally block its scent:
I guarantee you and your dog will have fun with this game.
Good dog, Pao Pao! You found all the goodies.